The New Mandate for Sports Leaders: Building Mentally Fit Athletes in a High-pressure Era

I am no stranger to pressure. I’ve led organizations where the stakes were high, the competition fierce, and the responsibility enormous. But long before the boardroom, I learned about pressure as a Division I football player—in locker rooms, under stadium lights, and in moments where grit, identity, and performance collided in real time. That experience shaped my understanding of what it truly means to lead under stress, to recover from setbacks, and to perform when expectations are unforgiving.

Today, as a national leader in athlete wellness and performance, I see that same pressure bearing down on young athletes—only now it arrives earlier, louder, and with far fewer safeguards. The responsibility we hold as administrators, coaches, and institutional leaders has never been greater. The decisions we make today are not just shaping athletes—they are shaping people.

In my role leading the National Sports Association of Wellness & Mental Fitness (NSAWMF), I’ve seen what happens when communities rally behind their athletes with clarity and alignment. I’ve also seen what happens when coaches, parents, and administrators are left to navigate modern pressures without the tools and training this era now demands.

THE EVOLVING CHALLENGES FACING SPORTS LEADERS

Leaders of athletic programs today are operating inside a convergence of unprecedented pressures: NIL economics, athlete mobility, constant social media visibility, rising sports betting exposure, intensifying public scrutiny, and increasing anxiety, burnout, and identity disruption among athletes. The new mandate for sports leaders is no longer simply to develop stronger bodies—it is to deliberately foster cultures where the mind is trained with the same discipline as the body.

Yet, the leadership system surrounding athletes has not kept pace with this reality.

A Coaches Leadership Index study found that 91% of coaches report they were never trained to handle athlete shutdown or burnout. This gap is not theoretical. It shows up weekly in locker rooms, classrooms, and training facilities across the country.

Mental fitness is no longer a secondary concern. It is now a core performance advantage. Administrators who align their leaders around this truth are better equipped to build cultures where athletes thrive—on and off the field—long after the final whistle.

SETTING THE STANDARD FOR ATHLETE WELL-BEING IS A COLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITY

Across the country, institutions are acknowledging what families and athletes have felt for years: today’s athletes are under historic pressure

The 2022 NCAA Coach Well-Being Study revealed that more than 80% of coaches now spend significant time addressing athlete mental health concerns, with many citing it as the most pressing issue their teams face.

True athlete well-being requires collective alignment between administrators, coaches, parents, counselors, and institutions. Mental fitness is the mechanism that builds mental resilience—the capacity to absorb shock, recover from adversity, and adapt under sustained pressure in both sport and life.

This work is about teaching athletes how to be tough with clarity, compete with confidence, regulate under pressure, and recover quickly from failure—without losing their identity in the process. In this era, toughness must be trained with intention.

That is precisely why NSAWMF exists: to provide science-backed education and support that equips the leaders of athletes to lead in a world where we now understand that the mind enables the body to perform.

ALIGNING LEADERSHIP AROUND A CULTURE OF MENTAL FITNESS

Transformation begins with alignment, not directives—and in today’s athletic environment, that alignment must start with coaches.

While administrators set the vision, it is coaches who translate culture into daily behavior. That is why the NSAWMF mental fitness model is intentionally designed for coaches first—equipping them with the tools, language, and leadership capacity to shape resilient athletes and teams in real time.

Our coach-centered framework aligns leadership across four interconnected levels:

1. Self as Leader. Coaches develop emotional intelligence, composure, and self-awareness.

2. The Individual Athlete. Coaches build confidence, recovery capacity, focus, and identity stability.

3. The Team. Coaches cultivate trust, accountability, and psychological safety as performance advantages.

4. Integrated Stakeholder Alignment. Coaches, administrators, parents, counselors, and community partners operate from a shared mental fitness language and expectations.

Administrators do not need to be mental performance experts. Their role is to invest in coach development, integrate stakeholder alignment, and hold the system accountable.

Developing coaches is not one element of our work—it is a cornerstone of our impact.

FROM SAFETY TO STRENGTH

Emotional and psychological safety are no longer optional—but safety alone is not the destination. Administrators shape the athletic environment through the leaders they hire, the behaviors they reinforce, and the standards they institutionalize. 

This means eliminating outdated “toughen up” practices that erode confidence without strengthening resilience, while embedding consistent accountability and leadership development across programs.  The goal is not simply to protect athletes but to strengthen them.

PROVIDING ACCESS TO MENTAL FITNESS & PERFORMANCE 

True advocacy is not just about access—it is about integration. Administrators can normalize mental fitness by embedding it into the daily rhythm of sport through partnerships with licensed professionals, brief mental fitness training in practice routines, and nonprofit collaborations that remove cost barriers.

The NCAA reports a 200% increase in athlete mental health–related service requests since 2019, underscoring the urgency for scalable, systemic solutions. Nonprofits like NSAWMF play a critical role in bridging these public-private resource gaps.

ACADEMIC ALIGNMENT AND HOLISTIC 

Athlete excellence cannot exist in isolation from academic and personal development.

When athletic departments, counseling services, and academic advisors operate in alignment, athletes experience coherence rather than conflict. Time management, emotional regulation, and purpose alignment are no longer soft skills—they are performance and life skills.

When programs develop the whole athlete, they do not just graduate competitors—they graduate leaders. 

NAVIGATING TRANSITIONS WITH INTEGRITY Transfers 

Recruiting, role changes, and injuries are emotionally charged flashpoints in an athlete’s journey—the moments that matter.

Administrators must ensure transparent recruiting policies, protection from predatory practices, emotional and academic counseling during transition, and stability for those who remain.

As NIL money, performance analytics, and betting exposure escalate pressure, ethical leadership and transparent communication become non-negotiable elements of mental fitness protection.

LEADING THROUGH ALIGNMENT 

Administrators hold the keys to sustainable transformation in athletics. Their power lies not in micromanaging programs but in aligning people, policies, and practices around mental fitness as a shared priority. When leaders across every level of an organization operate from the same mental fitness framework, cultures become more resilient, ethical, and performance driven.

Greatness starts in the mind—and the leaders who believe that first are the ones who build systems that endure. 

Join the National Sports Association of Wellness & Mental Fitness in helping administrators and athletic leaders align, train, and lead programs built on mental fitness, resilience, and performance integrity. Together, we can equip the next generation of athletes—and the leaders who serve them—for sustained success.

Are you ready to develop your mental fitness as an athlete? Join the National Sports Association of Wellness & Mental Fitness (NSAWMF) and become part of a community committed to total athletic development—mind, body, and spirit.

Become a Member

Disclaimer: The content provided by the National Sports Association of Wellness & Mental Fitness (NSAWMF) is for performance and developmental purposes. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional psychological advice, diagnosis, or treatment. If you are experiencing mental health challenges or emotional distress, please seek support from a licensed mental health professional. Always consult a qualified provider with any questions you may have regardin